Best Coffee Maker of 2018? Complete Reviews with Comparison

Best Coffee Maker of 2018 Complete Reviews with Comparison
Spread the love

Having coffee continuously available can be desirable in a number of circumstances. Obviously, it saves time, it is also more convenient, and if a visitor comes calling you can offer them a coffee immediately.

To have coffee 'on call' means having a coffee maker but which one is right for you.

They differ in many ways in terms of their capacity, operation, size, and features so it can be a tricky choice.

To assist you in making that choice our review looks at some the best coffee makers available and highlights the important features which differentiate them.

Comparison Chart

Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel
Cuisinart DCC-3200AMZ Coffeemaker, 14 Cup Stainless Steel
AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Switch Coffee Maker, Black
Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter, 1 Liter, 34 Ounce, Black Band
Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel
Cuisinart DCC-3200AMZ Coffeemaker, 14 Cup Stainless Steel
AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Switch Coffee Maker, Black
Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter, 1 Liter, 34 Ounce, Black Band
Price not available
Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel
Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel
Cuisinart DCC-3200AMZ Coffeemaker, 14 Cup Stainless Steel
Cuisinart DCC-3200AMZ Coffeemaker, 14 Cup Stainless Steel
Price not available
AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Switch Coffee Maker, Black
Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Switch Coffee Maker, Black
Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter, 1 Liter, 34 Ounce, Black Band
Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter, 1 Liter, 34 Ounce, Black Band

Best Coffee Makers Reviews

1. Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel

Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel

This is a simple coffee maker with the traditional setup of a glass carafe into which the brewed coffee is filtered and then kept warm. It is easy to use and is suitable for use at home or in an office environment.


Product Highlights

This coffee maker has a 5-cup capacity which is normal for this size of machine. It has a simple process which requires the addition of coffee powder, adding water to the reservoir, turning it on, and then waiting for the coffee to filter through into the carafe. After you have poured your first cup, the heating plate which the carafe sits on will keep the coffee warm.

To help you brew the exact amount you want there is a water window with measurement markings so that you can fill it to the level that is required.

As a safety measure, there is an automatic cut off to prevent continuous boiling and the possibility of the machine boiling dry. Any time the carafe is removed for pouring there could be an issue with coffee dripping from the coffee maker in the top section, but it has been designed to be drip free.

When you have finished making coffee with the machine, and want to clean the filter basket, it can be removed and cleaned in the dishwasher.

This coffee maker makes a great cup of coffee using a very simple process and is ideal for domestic or office use. For these reasons, we have chosen this as our best-rated coffee maker.

Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless Steel
  • COMPACT DESIGN: Perfectly sized 5-cup glass carafe is ideal for 1 or 2 people
  • GOLDTONE FILTER: Eliminates the need for messy paper filters and is easy to clean
  • PROGRAMMABLE: Set the machine to automatically brew at your programmed time
  • KEEP WARM: Hot plate stays on for 2 hours and then automatically turns off
  • DRIP STOP: Pour a cup while brewing

What's to like about the Aicok Drip Coffee Maker

One of the best features is that it can keep your coffee warm for up to 45 minutes, so no more cold coffee. If you are short for time in the meaning then set the timer 24 hours in advance. This will allow you to have your coffee ready by the time you wake up. What more could you ask for in a drip coffee maker

What's not to like about the Aicok Drip Coffee Maker

The only thing not to like is there seem to be pump issues. This can be quite problematic as the machine gets older and the only way is to get the pump replaced.


  • Simple to use
  • Durable glass carafe
  • Warming plate to keep coffee warm
  • Automatic safety cut off
  • Easy-clean filter basket


  • Carafe lid is flimsy
  • Narrow opening makes carafe difficult to clean

2. Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker

Cuisinart DCC-3200AMZ Coffeemaker, 14 Cup Stainless Steel

If you like your appliances to be high-tech or digital, then this Cuisinart not only fits into that category, it looks the part too. With a digital display and matte silver casing, this is certainly one of the most modern coffee makers you are likely to see.

Product Highlights

As we have already mentioned, this is a very modern coffee maker that makes use of state-of-the-art technology. It is fully automatic and can be programmed to operate up to 24 hours in advance. You can also control the strength of the coffee brewed, with settings for regular or bold coffee flavor. These controls are done via buttons on the front of the coffee maker and settings can be viewed on the backlit LCD display.

When the coffee is ready, you can set an option that will mean the machine emits a beep to let you know, and once you have you poured the coffee, a heated plate, whose temperature can be adjusted, will keep the coffee warm when you place the carafe back in its position.

Even though it uses micro-technology, there is nothing small about the capacity of this coffee maker. It can make up to 14 cups of coffee with just one filling up of its reservoir. When filling the reservoir, you can check the level by looking at the level indicator window.

The last thing to say about this coffee maker is how stunning it looks, which is not something we would normally expect to say about something which makes coffee. Its casing is made from stainless steel in keeping with the modern theme with black trimming. All of this combines to create a great addition to any kitchen countertop.

It may have all the technology but one of this coffee maker's biggest appeals is its 14-cup capacity. This is why we are selecting this as our best large-capacity coffee maker.

Cuisinart DCC-3200AMZ Coffeemaker, 14 Cup Stainless Steel
  • State-of-the-art technology to ensure hotter Coffee without sacrificing flavor or quality. Dimensions (LXWXH) : 7.75 x 9.00 x 14.00 inches
  • Brew strength control allows you to select regular or bold Coffee flavor
  • Fully automatic with 24-hour Programmability, self-clean, 1-4 cup setting and auto shutoff (0-4 hours)
  • Adjustable keep Warm temperature control
  • Gold tone, commercial style Permanent filter

What's to like about the Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker

Besides the fact it will keep your coffee hotter for longer, it also has an increased size of up to 14 cups. Compared to a lot of other models that use switches, this one uses push buttons which makes it a lot easier to use.

You might also notice overflow issues with other models - the Cuisinart PerfecTemp eliminates this issue by offering a larger basket and a much deeper reservoir.

What's not to like about the Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker

After prolonged use, there seems to be an issue with the water reservoir. If you do experience issues with this, it will need to be replaced.


This model tends to produce a lot of steam which can damage the underside of your cabinets, so it will be best not to place it underneath a cabinet.


  • Uses state-of-the-art technology
  • Fully automatic and programmable
  • Digital display
  • Adjustable heating plate
  • Large 14-cup capacity


  • Lengthy brewing time
  • Pouring spout dribbles occasionally

3. AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker

AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe

This coffee maker is ideal if you are looking for something simple to use, and don't see the need to spend hundreds of dollars on something which simply makes you a cup of coffee.

Product Highlights

Sometimes in the world of gadgets and appliances, it seems like manufacturers add features to products simply for the sake of it, or if we are being cynical about it, to inflate the price. So, it is great to see a coffee maker that is designed to do exactly that... make coffee.

First, we note that it doesn't take up much space on the countertop, which is great news if the space you have in your kitchen is limited. Although it is smaller than some, it still has the capacity to make up to 5 cups of coffee which should be sufficient for you to top your cup several times or offer coffee to guests after dinner.

It works on the normal basis of placing your coffee grounds in the top of the machine and then adding water. You can check the water level by looking at the level indicator on the side. The coffee is then filtered down, into the carafe below. One great feature is the fact that the filter is reusable, therefore saving you money by not having to buy disposable paper filters.

Once you have poured your first cup of coffee, the carafe can be replaced on the base of the coffee maker, where it can be kept warm by the plate it sits on. One point to note is that anytime you lift the carafe from the machine, the brewing process stops, therefore avoiding any drips.

The filter is removable so that you can clean it, and if you want to clean the carafe, it can be done by washing it in soapy water.

This coffee maker is ideal if you are on a tight budget or just don't see the need to spend lots of money on a coffee maker. Given its incredibly low price, this is our best budget coffee maker.

AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
  • Space-saving 5-cup coffeemaker brews up to 5 cups at a time (25 ounces or 740 ml)
  • Pour a cup mid-brew, then keep coffee warm while you finish your drink
  • Removable filter basket and reusable filter (no need for paper filters)
  • Carafe is hand wash only (not dishwasher safe)
  • Backed by an AmazonBasics limited one-year warranty

What's to like about the AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker

One thing that many people love about this model is the reusable filter. Filters are expensive, so you will be able to save a lot of money with the AmazonBasics coffeemaker. It also heats up quickly which will reduce the waiting time it takes to get your freshly brewed cup of coffee.

What's not to like about the AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker

It says it is a 5-cup coffeemaker, but you can get about two large cups out of there. There is no auto-shutoff which should be a standard basic feature that all coffeemakers should have.


  • Re-usable filter
  • Keep warm function
  • Easy to operate
  • Space saving size
  • Excellent value for your money


  • No auto cut-off
  • Filter lid is very tight

4. Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Switch Coffee Maker, Black

This another coffee maker which makes use of modern technology to make the task of making coffee as easy as possible. It is programmable, so you can set it up in advance to deliver great coffee whenever you want it.

Product Highlights

This Mr. Coffee programmable coffee maker is truly up to date when it comes to using technology to make every coffee drinker’s life as easy as possible. It can be pre-programmed to switch on and make your coffee so that it is piping hot, and fully brewed at just the right moment. This could be for when you wake in the morning or when you expect to arrive home from work.

Operating the coffee maker is done by the simple control panel at the front, where there is also an LCD display to indicate the programmed time, for example. There is also a delayed brew function, which will pause the machine whilst you lift the carafe off to pour a cup of coffee.

Although it's an automatic coffee maker you still have some manual work to do, such as the coffee grounds and the water. You can see the water level as you pour it in because there is a clear indicator located on the side of the machine. The filter basket is removable for cleaning and for whenever you want to change the filter.

The carafe capacity is only 4 cups so this coffee maker isn't going to be one you would use for large dinner parties, but solo use or for couples it is a perfect size. The size of the coffee maker means it does not take up much room and should, therefore, be able to sit neatly on most kitchen countertops.

The ease with which you can use this machine is fantastic and with the pre-programming features making it even easier, we have no hesitation in designating this our best automatic coffee maker.

Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Switch Coffee Maker, Black
  • On/off indicator light lets you know when your coffee maker is on or off
  • Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause stops cycle if you need a cup before brewing is finished
  • Dual water window allows visibility as you fill—no more overflows
  • Removable filter basket for quick and easy cleanup
  • Stain-resistant warming plate is easy to clean

What's to like about the Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

A brew-strength regulator ensures the coffee maker allows users to adjust the taste of their coffee, and therefore, offering you convenience right at your fingertips.

It also comes with a 24-hour timer which will allow you to program the coffee maker to begin brewing at a particular time each day. To top it off, it has a digital display showing the time and brew status of your coffee.

What's not to like about the Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

The non-stick warming plate is a flaw since the non-stick warming plate wears off after awhile. Also, you have to put the filter in just right and snap it in place, which can sometimes be challenging.


  • Automatic operation
  • LCD display
  • Pre-programmable
  • Delay brew function
  • Removable filter basket


  • Limited capacity – 4 cups
  • Carafe handle is small

5. Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker

Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter, 1 Liter, 34 Ounce, Black Band

In these days of automation and microprocessors, it is sometimes great to see a product that takes us back to basics. That is exactly what this Bodum coffee maker does.

Product Highlights

There's no gizmos or gadgets, to make your coffee with this coffee maker. Instead, you simply add your coffee grounds into the top and then pour in boiling water. Once it has filtered through into the carafe below, you can then pour yourself a cup of fresh, delicious coffee.

The filter in this coffee maker is permanent so you are not required to continually buy and replace paper filters. It is made from stainless steel mesh which, unlike paper filters, does not absorb any oils from the coffee. This means all the flavor is retained, rather than diminished as in the case with paper filters.

The carafe is made from durable borosilicate glass which is heat resistant. This has two advantages. The first is that the coffee inside will retain its heat, and second, it protects your hands from getting burned when lifting the carafe.

The capacity of the carafe is an impressive 8 cups; therefore, even if you have several guests you should be able to offer all of them a cup of coffee from a single pouring over. The coffee maker is dishwasher safe, therefore when you have finished using it, you can place it in there for easy cleaning.

The neck of the carafe is surrounded by a colored band which can provide a better grip when lifting. There are numerous color options for this band, so you can choose the one that most suits your decor.

We love the raw coffee-making nature of this coffee maker, especially as pour-over coffee making gives you the maximum flavor. We are therefore going to award this our best pour-over coffee maker.

Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter, 1 Liter, 34 Ounce, Black Band
  • Pour over Coffee: manual pour over Coffee maker allows you to brew an excellent cup of Coffee in minutes
  • Stainless steel: includes a Permanent, stainless steel mesh filter that helps extract your coffee's aromatic oils and subtle flavors instead of being absorbed by a paper filter
  • Coffee carafe: made of durable, heat-resistant borosilicate glass with color band detailing that is both functional and elegant
  • Quick and easy: simply add coarse ground Coffee to filter, pour a small amount of water in a circular motion over ground Coffee until soaked then add the remaining water and let drip
  • Servings: pour over Coffee maker makes 8 cups of Coffee, 4 oz. each; dishwasher safe

What's to like about the Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker

Unlike other coffee makers, the Bodum coffee maker offers consumers natural flavors, a sweet aroma, and slowly brewed coffee.

The coffee maker contains a permanent, reusable stainless mesh filter made from steel, hence, no usage of paper filters.  It is perhaps among the easiest coffee makers, with no complicated buttons and settings to worry about. It is also easy to maintain!

What's not to like about the Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker

The Bodum Pour over Coffee Maker does not have a handle for protection from heat, and therefore you have to be very careful when picking it up. It is difficult to pour the coffee, as the sprout does not function as well as previous models.


  • Very easy to use
  • Retains the maximum coffee flavor
  • Reusable stainless steel filter
  • Carafe is made of durable glass
  • Color options to suit decor


  • Water can filter through too quickly
  • Coffee granules sometimes filter through


The term 'coffee maker' will seem like a very broad term to some, as literally anything that can make you a cup of coffee could, in theory, be called a coffee maker. However, what we are discussing here are coffee makers which work using a filter into which coffee beans or grounds are placed. Water is then heated, which filters through the coffee and into a carafe which sits underneath.

These types of coffee makers have several different features, sizes, and functions, so let's check what the most important things are to look for.

Coffee Maker Brands

As with many products, there are some coffee maker brands which are better known than others. Cuisinart are known for producing many different types of kitchen appliances. Mr. Coffee is also a recognizable name, and have been around since 1970, They specialize in coffee makers and accessories.

Bodum makes all sorts of kitchen essentials including cutlery, pots, and pans, while Aicok makes everything from milk frothers to toasters. The last brand in our selection is Amazon, who have recently started selling their own branded products in just about every category you can imagine.


The capacity of your coffee maker is important, especially if you love pouring multiple refills for yourself or want to use your coffee maker when entertaining guests.

At the lower end of the range are those with a 4- or 5-cup capacity which might be best suited for personal use. At the top end, we have a 14-cup capacity, which is perfect for dinner parties or when you have many visitors.

Brew Pause

This is a function found on electric coffee makers that pauses your coffee maker, while you remove the carafe to pour out coffee. Without the pause function, the machine would continue to operate, and coffee would drip down a create a mess on to the plate or base that the carafe would normally be sitting on.

On some models, the brew pause function is activated by a spring-loaded sensor or switch which is triggered as you lift the carafe off its plate. On others, you must manually press a button on the machine, which in turn activates the pause function.

Strength Setting

On those coffee makers which have electronic controls, you can adjust how strong or how weak you would like your coffee to be. This alters the flow and the time which water filters through the coffee to give the differences in strength.


Most coffee makers use paper filters which are disposable and need replenishing. For most people, this is not an issue but if you don't like the idea of having to spend additional money, or have environmental concerns regarding the use of paper, there is an alternative.

Some coffee makers use a stainless steel mesh filter, which is permanent, with the added benefit that it maintains more of the coffee's flavors.


How do I use the Cuisinart coffee maker?

The Cuisinart coffee maker gives you so many options thanks to its electronic controls. Here you can set preferences such as coffee strength and can also be programmed to have your coffee ready for a specific time.

You will need to add coffee to your filter, which is very easy to do; then, add water to the tank and use the level window to check you added the correct amount. Then you simply switch it on, and the machine will start brewing

How do I stop my coffee maker overflowing?

The first thing to do is ensure that your coffee maker is clean throughout. This especially applies to the filter basket. Ensure you get rid of any loose coffee grinds, water, and coffee which may have been spilled.

Another cause might be that you are overfilling the machine with coffee grounds. Try using fewer coffee grounds to see if this helps. On the subject of coffee grounds, if they are very fine, this can cause overflowing too. Try switching to a coffee whose granules are bigger.

How do I descale my coffee maker?

If you have noticed a white chalky residue in your coffee or if it starts to taste a bit off, then it may be time to descale your coffee maker. To do so you will need water and distilled white vinegar.

Empty your coffee maker and ensure there is no residue or coffee grounds left inside. Fill the carafe with the water and vinegar in equal measures. Pour this solution into the water tank. Switch on the coffee maker and let it run through half a brew cycle before switching it off. Let the machine sit for one hour. After the hour is up, continue the brew cycle until it ends.

Pour out the solution and rinse the carafe thoroughly with water. Now you fill the water tank with water, and then let the machine run a full brew cycle. Repeat at least twice to remove any traces of the vinegar smell or taste.


Choosing the best coffee maker for yourself will very much depend on what you are buying it for. You might want something which has a capacity large enough to be used at dinner parties, or you want one which is suitable for use for just one person. Alternatively, you might like your coffee maker to be full of high tech automation, or may prefer the simplest option of a pour-over coffee maker.

If it is automation you like, then the one we'd recommend is the Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker. It has lots of great functions and is thus our best automatic coffee maker. At the other end of the scale, we have our best pour-over coffee maker which is the Bodum Coffee Maker. Very easy to use, but it still makes a great cup of coffee.

For those who want to make as much coffee at a time as you can, then go for our best large-capacity coffee maker, which is the Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14 Cup Programmable Coffeemaker. This will make you 14 cups of coffee, with the bonus of being programmable too.

Keeping costs down may be a consideration for you when choosing a coffee maker; therefore, your choice should the AmazonBasics 5-Cup Coffeemaker. This our best budget coffee maker, and while the price may be low, the quality of the coffee it makes is very high.

Finally, we come to our best rated coffee maker, which is awarded to the Aicok Drip Coffee Maker. It's very simple to use, easy to clean and makes a great cup of coffee.

Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: